I recently finished Shauna Niequist's book Cold Tangerines. I'm a sucker for these kinds of books. Gratitude. Celebrating the everyday. And who can resist that lovely orange cover? It just screams, "Read me!"
So, I expected to love this book. But then I read these words, and I realized that the author and I weren't going to get along too well.
"I'm not a doctrinarian, mostly because for me, doctrine is not the thing that God has used to change my life. I'm a reader and a storyteller, and God chose literature and story and poetry as the languages of my spiritual text."
But, when our lives are not built on sound doctrine, we distort a host of things, including forgiveness and gratitude. Our lives reflect our doctrine, and certainly a gratitude not grounded in sound doctrine is a me-oriented gratitude instead of a God-honoring gratitude. How do we live a life that is poured out for His glory if we have so little understanding of WHO He is and what
He has done?
Here are some of the ways Niequist's low regard of doctrine works itself out:
"And I still have to keep letting her off, every day, sometimes several times a day. Not for her sake, but for mine, because I want off the hook. It's hard work, and I don't want to do it, but I keep doing it. I keep letting her off the hook, because when I do, I can breathe again."
"So now, out of desperation, I'm back to prayer. I'm back to prayer, sheepishly, because I couldn't make my life work without it. I pray out of sheer lack of options."
"To borrow a phrase, I don't really care about preaching to the choir. They've got lots of good preaching coming at them already. I really, really care about women like me, like my friends and students who can't find themselves in a really traditional religious environment, even though they love God or at least want to understand more about Him. So being called, essentially, 'not Christian enough' doesn't really bother me. It's a different conversation."
"...I flew to Chicago, because one of my oldest and dearest friends was getting married and asked me to officiate the ceremony."
"Last winter, I did a study of Exodus. Not the kind of Bible study I'm used to, because I usually do the kind where a bunch of friends meet at someone's house or a coffee shop and occasionally we do the actual study but mostly we talk and tell stories and pray at the end."
"One look at a baby's fingers and you just know that those little bundles of flesh and tiny bones are more sacred, more spiritual, than any thought or idea or theology could ever be."
"Because it seems like that's what God is saying to us, over and over. 'What can I do today to remind you again how good this life is?"
I enjoyed much of Niequist's writing, but I can't ignore her disregard for sound doctrine. But, Trisha, you're just being a curmudgeon, you say. No, I'm not. Niequist has an obligation to speak the truth since she claims the name of Christ, and it's because she claims His name that she's held to a greater accountability. There's a flabbiness to Niequist's theology, and it often sounds like she's proud of that.
Does doctrine matter? In the words of my friend, Norma, yes it does.
"Yes. The more you study it, the stronger you foundation will be and the harder will be to fall, although you will fall. You'll have a greater understanding of His love, mercy, grace, patience, goodness. The more you dig deeper into the Word, the more you will love Him and the more you will want to live for Him. Your view of Christ, His sacrifice, His atonement, His life, His resurrection, His priesthood, His sovereignty, His glory, His holiness, my wretched condition without Him, prayer, mortification of sin, my dependence on Him, the role of the woman in her house, at church, with her children, with other women, all these will come into place. It will be easier to spot lies from truth (no matter how sweet they may appear) because you will know the truth. The truth will be your daily bread, and the lie will quickly taste as food not prepared at home. You will identify it with God's grace."
Praise God for thanksgiving that flows from sound doctrine.
With love,
Trisha